Charcoal Versus Gas Grills Reviews

When it comes to grilling, people have plenty of opinions on what works best. One of those many debates is the infamous “charcoal vs gas grill” debate, or whether or not a charcoal grill or a gas grill is better than the other.

Both have their pros and cons, which is why we are going to explore all of the different facets of both charcoal and gas grills. Read on for all of the information you need to make an informed decision.

How We Gathered Our Information

How Do Charcoal Grills Work?

How Do Gas Grills Work?

How Much Does a Charcoal Grill Cost?

How Much Does a Gas Grill Cost?

Latest Charcoal Grill Models

Kingsford 14"Black Portable Grill

Kingsford 14"Black Portable Grill - Black (TG2021302)

One of the most notable charcoal grill brands is Kingsford, though they primarily sell their popular bags of charcoal. One grill that they offer is the 14” Black Portable Grill for $19.99, a portable and adorable choice for grillers on the go.

Kingsford 30" Barrel Charcoal Grill

Kingsford 30" Barrel Charcoal Grill

There are also bigger options available for charcoal grills, such as the Kingsford 30’’ Barrel Grill which is currently on sale at Walmart for $67.28 (originally $119.00). It has consistently received good reviews.

Sale
Kingsford GR1031-014984 Barrel Charcoal Grill, 30-Inch
  • 793 sq.in. cooking area
  • Cast iron cooking grate
  • Expand metal side shelves and bottom rack

Weber 441001 Original Kettle 18-Inch Charcoal Grill

Weber 441001 Original Kettle 18-Inch Charcoal Grill

Other brands and models have also been received well in the charcoal grilling community, including the Weber 441001 Original Kettle 18-Inch Charcoal Grill voted as an Amazon Top Choice. It retails for $79.

Sale
Weber 441001 Original Kettle 18-Inch Charcoal Grill
  • Kettle grill with 240 square inches of total cooking space
  • 18-1/2-inch-diameter plated-steel cooking grate; rust-resistant vents
  • Porcelain-enameled bowl and lid with glass-reinforced nylon handles

Dyna-Glo Signature Series DGSS675CB-D Heavy-Duty Barrel Charcoal Grill

Traeger® Lil' Pig Pellet Grill – Pink

In the $200 range, the Dyna-Glo Signature Series Heavy Duty Barrel Charcoal Grill retails for $280.49 and features both a grill and cooking zone for multiple cooking needs. It is a cylinder shape and takes up more space than the basic rounded charcoal grills, but comes with more accessories and features like the temperature monitor and a heat resistant handle grip.

Sale
Dyna-Glo Signature Series DGSS675CB-D Heavy-Duty Barrel Charcoal Grill
  • Total cooking area is 675 Square inches
  • Cool-touch spring lid handles
  • Warming shelf on offset smoker box lid
Dyna-Glo Signature Series DGSS675CB-D Heavy-Duty Barrel Charcoal Grill

There are even uniquely-shaped grills out there such as the Traegar Lil’ Pig Pellet Grill, which is a charcoal grill in the shape of a pink pig, presumably for pig pickins’ and barbeques.

While these grills are not the only available options for charcoal grills, they are a few different charcoal grills that help show the wide range of options.

Traeger Lil' Pig Wood Fired Grill
  • Traeger Wood-Fired Grills

Latest Gas Grill Models

Weber 51060001 Q1200 Liquid Propane Grill

Weber 51060001 Q1200 Liquid Propane Grill

Weber is a popular brand for gas grill models and consistently shows up on searches for current gas grills. The Weber Q 1200 Propane Gas Grill is one best-selling choice of gas grill from Weber, its size at only 189 inches with full power from an infinite controller valve. It is also rated around five stars, is portable, and affordable, retailing for $199.

Sale
Weber 51060001 Q1200 Liquid Propane Grill
  • One stainless steel burner produces 8500 BTU-per-hour to heat 189 square-inch total cooking area
  • Porcelain-enameled cast-iron cooking grates and cast aluminum lid and body
  • Fully assembled out of box

Coleman Classic Propane Stove

Coleman Classic Propane Stove

The number one bestselling gas grill on Amazon is the Coleman Classic Propane Stove, which functions as both a stove and grill. It boasts about its portability and great use for camping trips. It is a very affordable model, retailing at $32.99.

Sale
Weber 51060001 Q1200 Liquid Propane Grill
  • One stainless steel burner produces 8500 BTU-per-hour to heat 189 square-inch total cooking area
  • Porcelain-enameled cast-iron cooking grates and cast aluminum lid and body
  • Fully assembled out of box

Napoleon 51" Freestanding Liquid Propane Grill

Napoleon 51" Freestanding Liquid Propane Grill

As for more expensive options, the Napoleon 51″ Freestanding Grill 35″ Cooking Surface is available in both liquid propane as well as natural gas. It comes with cooking grids tube burners, and other features that make the model more advanced than cheaper ones. This model is pricier, listed at $658.30, which is a reduction in the original retail price of $810.

Napoleon Rogue 425 Grill on Cart (R425NK), Natural Gas
  • Natural gas grill with stainless steel construction and chrome accents
  • Dimensions: 25L x 51W x 48H in.
  • 425-square inch main cooking area

So, Which One is Better?

So, how will the charcoal vs gas grill debate end? Before we can address which type of grill is better, we need to explore the pros and cons of both grills equally.

For starters, many people comment on the different taste that food has based on whether or not it was cooked on a gas grill versus a charcoal grill. Charcoal grills are notorious for being a bit messier than a gas grill because of the soot and other residue left behind after cooking. However, people notice the difference in the taste saying that they like the smoky charcoal taste as opposed to the more straightforward taste from the gas grill.

Others have cited concerns about the potential toxins that can seep into food with either grill, though many have feared the presence of carcinogens in charcoal. However, no big studies have suggested that charcoal grilling is permanently dangerous.

As for which is cheaper, most charcoal grills are cheaper to buy than a gas grill, but you can easily find options on both sides that are affordable. Brand new charcoal grills are easily available for under $100, while it is much harder to find a new gas grill under $100.  As previously mentioned, there are plenty of charcoal and gas grills that are similarly priced, but gas grills have a more expensive range.

As for setup, gas grills have a lot more parts laced into the product, as opposed to a standard charcoal grill which has just three main sections a griller would have to worry about. If you are just beginning grilling, a gas grill may not be the most user-friendly option. Troubleshooting or performing maintenance on a gas grill may be more confusing than a charcoal grill with all of the extra valves and tubing.

But many people argue that gas grills are more energy efficient and environmentally cleaner than a charcoal grill, as it does not produce toxic fumes or smoke in the air around the grilling area. It can be hard to get rid of the charcoal smell in clothes or even within a house if grilling is prolonged and near an open door.

The Final Verdict on Charcoal vs Gas Grills

Some experts like to take a different approach to the debate. The New York Times argues that the argument should not be which one is better, but rather which is better for a certain kind of food. That is not to say that each household should own both a charcoal and a gas grill, but that they should rather choose a grill based on what kinds of food they like to consume.

Though it is a non-committal answer, the ultimate choice completely depends on an individual’s tastes and interests. For those who are concerned about the environment, a gas grill might be the better option. For those looking for a simple backyard grill for not too much money without sacrificing taste, a charcoal grill may be the right option. So. the debate between charcoal vs. gas grill will probably continue for a long time.

Focus keyword: charcoal vs gas grill

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here